Logo Landing Page Logo HAW Hamburg

Air Transport versus High-Speed Rail: From Physics to Economics

Hayk Gregorian

Abstract
Purpose - This bachelor thesis compares high-speed rail (HSR) transport with air transport. The investigation considers physical fundamentals, energy consumption, environmental impact, infrastructure and investment, market situations, passenger's selection criteria to choose transportation options, and overall economics. --- Methodology - The thesis combines an investigation of physical principles with a literature review. --- Findings - Steel wheels on steel rails show by far less rolling resistance to support the train's weight than drag due to lift (induced drag) to support the aircraft's weight. This leads to less energy consumption. HSR trains use electricity from an overhead line. Hence, the environmental impact of HSR also depends much on how the electricity is produced. Airplanes only need an air traffic control environment to connect airports. In contrast, HSR needs infrastructure to connect stations. The amount of necessary infrastructure depends on the geological conditions. For example, crossing mountains means high investment. Longer passages over water are infeasible for HSR. High-speed rail is superior to air transport when connecting megacities because the trains have higher transport capacity, offer higher service frequencies and mission reliability, shorter total travel time, shorter access time to stations, shorter unproductive waiting time in stations and potentially lower travel costs. HSR is a strong competitor to airline services and has replaced some short range flights. A comparison of HSR in different world regions shows differences in the market situation and in passenger's selection criteria for transportation options. --- Research limitations - The potential of high-speed rail was investigated mainly on busy routes with high service frequencies. A comprehensive network comparison between high-speed trains and airplanes was not done and could lead to somewhat different results. --- Practical implications - The report tries to contribute arguments to the discussion about alternatives to air travel. --- Social implications - With more knowledge people can make an educated choice between transport options, can vote with their feet, and can take a firm position in the public discussion. --- Originality/value - A general comparison of HSR and air transport from physical fundamentals to economics seemed to be missing.

Download full text: PDF/A TextGregorian.pdf    Size:  5.8M
Date:2019-03-22
Type of work: Bachelor Thesis
Advisor / Examiner:Dieter Scholz
Published by:Aircraft Design and Systems Group (AERO), Department of Automotive and Aeronautical Engineering, Hamburg University of Applied Sciences
This work is part of:transparent pin for text alignment Digital Library - Projects & Theses - Prof. Dr. Scholz --- http://library.ProfScholz.de pin
 
PERSISTENT IDENTIFIER:
URN: https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:gbv:18302-aero2019-03-22.011 (to reach this page)
DOI:https://doi.org/10.15488/4544
ARK:https://n2t.net/ark:/13960/t80k9zn68
No associated research data 
URLs registered with URN: Show all links associated with this text!
 
CATALOG ENTRY:
DNB: Check inclusion of this title in German National Library!
WorldCat: Check inclusion of this title in WorldCat!
DataCite: Check inclusion of this title in DataCite!
Google Scholar: Check inclusion of this title in Google Scholar!
Semantic Scholar: Check inclusion of this title in Semantic Scholar!
OpenAIRE: Check inclusion of this title in OpenAIRE!
BASE: Check inclusion of this title in BASE!
CORE: Check inclusion of this title in CORE!
Google: Check inclusion of this title in Google!
 
Keywords, German (GND): Luftverkehr,   Hochgeschwindigkeitszug,   Umweltbelastung,   Verkehrsmittelwahl
Keywords, English (LCSH): Airplanes,   High speed trains,   Economics,   Choice of transportation
Keywords, free: Luftfahrt, Flugmechanik, Energieverbrauch, Infrastruktur, Investition, Reisemarkt, Passagier, Wirtschaftswissenschaften, Aeronautics, Air traffic control, Physics, Energy consumption, Environmental impact analysis, Investments, Marketing, HSR
DDC: 629.13,    629.133340423,    625.2,    388.047
RVK: ZO 7610

© This work is protected by copyright

The work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License
CC BY-NC-SA
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0

CC-BY-NC-SA

Any further request may be directed to:
Prof. Dr.-Ing. Dieter Scholz, MSME
E-Mail see: http://www.ProfScholz.de

VISIBILITY:  (more)

Share this text:
Twitter LinkedIn Facebook XING Mendeley InternetArchive E-Mail

Print Friendly and PDF

Quote this text:
ISO 690:
GREGORIAN, Hayk, 2019. Air Transport versus High-Speed Rail: From Physics to Economics. Bachelor Thesis. Hamburg University of Applied Sciences, Aircraft Design and Systems Group (AERO). Available from: https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:gbv:18302-aero2019-03-22.011 [viewed YYYY-MM-DD].

Major results / graphical abstract:
Major results / graphical abstract

Front page:
Cover Page

LAST UPDATE:  12 December 2021
AUTHOR:  Prof. Dr. Scholz
IMPRESSUM (PDF)

E-Mail-Address
home  Prof. Dr. Scholz
home  Aircraft Design and Systems Group (AERO)
home  Aeronautical Engineering
home  Department of Automotive and Aeronautical Engineering
home  Faculty of Engineering and Computer Science
home  Hamburg University of Applied Sciences